Culture Electricity hydro hydro dams Manitoba National News News Power Failure: The impacts of hydro in northern Manitoba

‘We have to live with these changes everyday’: Norway House still struggling from hydro development

‘We have to live with these changes everyday’: Norway House still struggling from hydro development


That is Half 2 of a collection on hydro-impacted communities in Treaty 5 territory. Click on right here to entry different tales featured in Energy Failure: The impacts of hydro in Northern Manitoba.


Justin Brake
Ashley Brandson
APTN Information
It was mid-December, a number of years again when Chris Clarke was out on snowmobile close to his brother’s camp and trapline on Playgreen Lake.

He “hit an air pocket” and went via the ice into the shallow water under, he recollects.

“Almost drowned that time.”

His brother constructed a fireplace to heat Clarke up. The 2 spent hours making an attempt to haul the model new snowmobile out of the opening.

The daddy and fisherman “quit trapping for a couple years,” he says.

ChrisClarke: Norway House Fisherman's Co-op President Chris Clarke says despite his community's settlement with Hydro more than 20 years ago, the waters are still polluted, fish populations are dwindling, and his people are struggling to hold on to their way of life. Photo: Justin Brake/APTN

(Chris Clarke says regardless of his group’s settlement with Hydro, the waters are still polluted, fish populations are dwindling, and his individuals are struggling to maintain on to their lifestyle. Photograph: Justin Brake)

However the heightened risks related with waterways related to hydroelectric development weren’t sufficient to hold Clarke away eternally.

He returned to fishing and trapping, carrying on his household’s custom and dealing to protect his individuals’s lifestyle for future generations.

However that lifestyle has been threatened because the 1970s, he explains, when Manitoba Hydro started reengineering the lakes and rivers that Cree in Treaty 5 territory have lived alongside, and trusted, since time immemorial.


Watch Ashley Brandon’s story on the consequences of hydro development on northern Manitoba. 


“We have to live with these changes every day…”

Clarke is president of the Norway House Fisherman’s Cooperative, which represents 50 native fishers who work in a struggling business harvesting fish from Playgreen Lake, Lake Winnipeg and Kiskittogisu Lake.

At the moment he’s taking Wa Ni Ska Tan alliance members out in boat to present them the impacts hydro development has had on the waters and fisheries.

The boat weaves by means of a channel, a number of kilometres outdoors of Norway House, with cabins and houses scattered alongside the shore.

A crane towers above the tall grasses alongside the banks and watches the boat cross by.

Minutes later the channel opens up, revealing beams of daylight glimmering on Playgreen Lake’s pale inexperienced waters. There’s slight wind.

The boat passes dozens of islands, a few of them new, some decreased to the bedrock that when sat under their soil and vegetation, and others utterly submerged underwater.

All the islands have eroded because of fluctuating water ranges managed by Manitoba Hydro; they’re a hazard to fishermen and others who use the lake, Clarke explains.

(The Norway House Fisherman’s Co-op, established in 1962, represents 50 business fishers from the Norway House space. Photograph: Justin Brake/APTN)

A 20-minute boat experience takes the alliance members—there to witness and doc the impacts of hydro development on native individuals and communities—to a small plant owned by the Fisherman’s Co-op.

It’s right here the fishermen land their catches of whitefish, pickerel and sauger and package deal it for transportation by truck 800 kilometres to Winnipeg, the place the fish is additional processed and marketed.

Standing on the dock and peering out on the lake, Clarke says the co-op’s fishers are working with a considerably decreased quota and sometimes wrestle to make ends meet.

“The silting is killing this lake because it’s killing the oxygen: the plant life, the fish — the fish can’t spawn here anymore.”

(Lands have been blasted and excavated to create Two-Mile Channel, which connects Playgreen Lake to Lake Winnipeg. Photograph: Justin Brake/APTN)

He says sturgeon—culturally vital to the Cree however now listed as an endangered species—have been as soon as plentiful within the lake however have virtually totally disappeared because the wave of hydro development within the area 4 many years in the past.

Clarke says timber are continually falling into the lake due to the shoreline erosion, and that they pose a security danger to fishermen.

As in different hydro-impacted communities, Manitoba Hydro pays locals from Norway House to retrieve timber and different particles so as to scale back the security danger, he explains.

Fluctuating water ranges additionally create air pockets beneath the ice in wintertime, just like the one Clarke fell by way of a couple of years in the past.

Some have given up fishing altogether, he says.

“We have to live with these changes everyday. Day in, day out, while we’re out here trying to make a living, providing for our families.”


Dispossessed by hydro

Within the 1960s, Manitoba and the federal authorities collectively explored the hydro potential of the Nelson River as a supply of energy for the rising power wants within the south.

The Nelson drains into Lake Winnipeg and runs greater than 600 kilometres to Hudson Bay.

With a drainage basin that spans greater than 1 million sq. kilometres throughout a number of provinces, it’s additionally an necessary waterway for the Cree, Metis and different Indigenous peoples within the area.

However by the 1970s, Manitoba Hydro had turned the river, its tributaries, and different waterways within the area into energy-and-profit-producing entities.

In accordance to Hydro’s web site, The Churchill River Diversion (CRD) “was created to increase the water flow to our large generating stations on the lower Nelson River”, with a lot of the Churchill’s stream “diverted at Southern Indian Lake into the Nelson River.”

Hydro describes a community of dams and channels that management the river’s movement into South Indian Lake and Cut up Lake, with the result being a mean of “25% more water [flowing] into the Nelson River system.”

On the similar time, because it was re-engineering the Churchill River system, Hydro additionally undertook the Lake Winnipeg Regulation (LWR), one other large engineering feat that “created a second outlet for Lake Winnipeg and a network of channels and structures,” in accordance to Hydro’s web site.

Hydro boasts that the Jenpeg dam and a collection of diversion channels “increase [Lake Winnipeg’s] outflow potential by about 50%” and assist “reduce overland flooding in summer.”

In writing, the Churchill River Diversion and Lake Winnipeg Regulation tasks sound comparatively innocent.

However for the Indigenous peoples whose existence and well-being are intimately related to these waters, a actuality of destruction, disorientation, and dispossession unfolded.

The Churchill River’s movement was utterly reversed, affecting fish migration and spawning. Fish that did survive have been discovered to have elevated ranges of mercury.

Rivers and lakes individuals as soon as travelled on, swam in and drank from, turned inexperienced after the flooding, their ranges and currents unpredictable.

Those that carried conventional information of the rivers and lakes’ nature and behavior discovered themselves unable to navigate the waters.

Lands have been flooded, together with burial websites and different sacred areas. Individuals have been uprooted from their ancestral homelands and compelled to relocate to accommodate the brand new reservoirs.

Influxes of southerners to their communities through the development phases of dams, powerlines and different infrastructure created social issues.

The Cree’s lifestyle was dramatically altered.

A 1993 report on the NFA ready for the Royal Fee on Aboriginal Peoples describes the “systematic degradation of the local economy,” ensuing from hydro development within the area.

“Many persons or households find themselves incapable of coping with economic and social disruption,” the report continues, explaining many have been pressured out of the conventional land-based financial system and on to “welfare”.

(The Jenpeg producing station close to Norway House Cree Nation. Photograph: Ashley Brandson/APTN)

In Norway House, it was the Two- and Eight-Mile Channels that introduced an inflow of water into Playgreen and Little Playgreen Lakes from Lake Winnipeg.

And the 115-megawatt Jenpeg dam 100 kilometres north of the group that held these waters again.

Most of Norway House’s individuals, as soon as members of a group on the coronary heart of the 18th and 19th century fur commerce, and within the 19th century the beneficiaries of a thriving fishery, started witnessing the top of a lifestyle.


The Northern Flood Settlement and damaged guarantees 

In 1974, as a number of dams have been underneath development on the Nelson River and flooding continued to devastate to Cree communities, the chiefs of 5 First Nations—Nelson House, Norway House, Cross Lake, York Touchdown and Cut up Lake—shaped the Northern Flood Committee to negotiate compensation for his or her individuals.

In 1977 they signed the Northern Flood Settlement (NFA) with Manitoba Hydro, the Authorities of Manitoba, and the Authorities of Canada.

The NFA promised to compensate First Nations with reserve lands impacted by the flooding, chief amongst these guarantees “a commitment and schedule to investigate plans for alleviating mass unemployment and poverty in the communities,” says Peter Kulchyski, a professor of Native Research on the College of Manitoba.

“And Article 6 was an open-ended commitment from the federal government to ensure a continuous supply of potable water that meet the federal government’s water, health and safety standards,” he provides.

Kulchyski, a co-founder of Wa Ni Ska Tan who has labored with hydro-impacted communities in northern Manitoba for greater than 20 years, says the NFA’s key commitments have been by no means met.

“I think [Manitoba] Hydro thought they were going to make so much money they wouldn’t know what to do with it, and they were going to throw some money at these communities and they’d be fine,” he says.

However the guarantees proved too pricey for Hydro, from a monetary standpoint, Kulchyski explains.

“The community needs, and also the environmental impacts, I think were far greater than they anticipated,” he says, including the provincial utility “still touts hydro as clean power — but that’s now in absolute denial.”

From Canada’s perspective, Kulchyski figures the feds have been “very apprehensive about their water dedication and the price of that, particularly once they noticed that…it wasn’t going to be protected to drink the water from the river.

“So suddenly supplying fresh water to the communities was an expensive proposition,” he explains.

With provincial and federal governments and Manitoba Hydro largely unwilling or unable to fulfill their guarantees to the communities, they “went community by community, offering them various packages of some hundreds of millions of dollars,” Kulchyski continues, “if the communities would sign an agreement that said they would no longer pursue any legal action under the NFA.”

4 of the 5 NFA Nations, excluding Cross Lake, signed what Hydro has referred to as “implementation agreements”.

Or, as Kulchyski calls them, “extinguishment agreements”.

“They are basically agreements saying ‘we won’t live up to our promises under the NFA and you’ll get some money instead,’” he says.


Money compensation “never going to be enough”: councillor

 

(An indication by the Jenpeg producing station warns of a quickly altering water ranges. Photograph: Ashley Brandson/APTN)

Norway House signed its implementation settlement in 1997.

The $78.9 million deal compensated the group for the harms hydro had inflicted on its individuals.

Over the previous 20 years the band has used the cash to construct housing, a multi-use facility, and to fund packages locally.

Band councillor Langford Saunders says most of that cash is now spent, although some stays invested however not producing as a lot curiosity because the band council hoped.

But with some new infrastructure and a number of other now-defunct packages, Saunders says the impacts of hydro development on his group proceed.

The seashores he grew up enjoying on are still gone due to the flooding.

The shortage of protected locations for younger individuals to swim or fish, coupled with worry of getting sick from the once-clean waters, is still maintaining youth off the land, he says.

Saunders, who was elected to council earlier this yr, says he’s hopeful Hydro will work with his group to make sure the individuals of Norway House are compensated for the lack of their lifestyle.

On the similar time, “it’s never going to be enough,” he says.

“My opinion is we can’t put a price on the loss of the activities we used to do prior to the construction of the two channels [on Playgreen Lake]. We’ve lost a lot, and there’s not enough compensation to compensate for that.”

Saunders says Hydro’s “commitment to support the community has to continue.”

APTN Information requested an interview with Manitoba Hydro for this collection. They declined, however spokesperson Bruce Owen emailed a written assertion.

“We recognize the impact hydro-electric development has had on many Indigenous communities,” he says. “We also recognize that resolving past grievances is fundamental to strengthening our relationships with Indigenous communities.”

APTN additionally reached out to Manitoba’s Minister of Indigenous and Northern Relations, Eileen Clarke, who declined our interview request.

“Hydro has altered our way of life,” Clarke says, standing on the shore at Two-Mile Channel after displaying Wa Ni Ska Tan members how Hydro re-engineered the land and waters between Playgreen Lake and Lake Winnipeg.

“It’s altered everything. And what upsets me is they don’t show us proper regard or respect,” he continues.

“Positive, the injury is completed already, however how can we reduce it? How can we assist the lake survive?

“Sometime I would like to see my grandchildren…or my sons, proceed this lifestyle that I’ve loved.

“Trapping, hunting, fishing. It’s who we are as Cree people. The lake and the land were loaned to us by the Creator for us to survive. I want people to understand that. Life is not all rosy, and we have issues to deal with, but we try our best to live.”

jbrake@aptn.ca

@justinbrakenews

abrandson@aptn.ca

@ashleybrandson





!perform(f,b,e,v,n,t,s)if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=perform()n.callMethod?
n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments);if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n;
n.push=n;n.loaded=!zero;n.model=’2.zero’;n.queue=[];t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!zero;
t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)(window,
doc,’script’,’https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js’);
fbq(‘init’, ‘1900586643519394’); // Insert your pixel ID right here.
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);

!perform(f,b,e,v,n,t,s)if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=perform()n.callMethod?
n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments);if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n;
n.push=n;n.loaded=!zero;n.model=’2.zero’;n.queue=[];t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!zero;
t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)(window,
doc,’script’,’https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js’);
fbq(‘init’, ‘528100980648029’); // Insert your pixel ID right here.
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);

!perform(f,b,e,v,n,t,s)if(f.fbq)return;n=f.fbq=perform()n.callMethod?
n.callMethod.apply(n,arguments):n.queue.push(arguments);if(!f._fbq)f._fbq=n;
n.push=n;n.loaded=!zero;n.model=’2.zero’;n.queue=[];t=b.createElement(e);t.async=!zero;
t.src=v;s=b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)(window,
doc,’script’,’https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js’);
fbq(‘init’, ‘1900586643519394’); // Insert your pixel ID right here.
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);