Colonialism Cree environment Featured hydroelectric development Manitoba Hydro National News Nelson House News Nisichawayasi Nehethowuk Nisichawayasihk Northern Flood Agreement Power Failure: The impacts of hydro dams in Northern Manitoba Treaty 5 Wuskwatim

Dam partnership has not changed nature of hydro development in Nisichaswayasihk, say members

Edward Linklater


Justin Brake
Ashley Brandson
APTN Information
Nelson Home, residence to the Nisichawayasi Nehethowuk, sits alongside the north shore of Footprint Lake, about 700 kilometres north of Winnipeg, 500 from Hudson Bay, and on the convergence of the Footprint, Rat and Burntwood Rivers.

For the members of Nisichawayasihk Cree Nation (NCN), it’s additionally the epicentre of one of the best occasions to influence their id and method of life.

Their ancestors have made the lands across the convergence of the three rivers their residence for hundreds of years, the place they fished the bountiful waters and hunted and trapped the huge, hilly panorama.

The native land-based financial system advanced by way of settlers’ enlargement into the world, which included the institution of North West Firm and Hudson Bay buying and selling posts in the area in the late 1700s and early 1800s.

100 years later a Roman Catholic day faculty was constructed, one run by people who locals have claimed in current years sexually abused them. The varsity was half of the church and state’s wider effort to assimilate Indigenous youngsters into Canadian society.

Regardless of the disruptions to their lives, the Nisichawayasi Nehethowuk nonetheless hunted and fished for themselves, their households, kin and group properly into the 20th century.

However in the 1970s hydro development posed a brand new menace. One which didn’t goal the individuals, or animals, however somewhat the factor the individuals and the animals depend upon — the water.

Displaced by Hydro

Carol Kobliski is 53 years previous.

She grew up on a small island in the center of Footprint Lake and remembers the day Manitoba Hydro confirmed up on the door.

“They came to our cabin and told my mom and dad they had to move off the island,” she recalled in a current telephone interview with APTN Information.

Kobliski stated her household was provided $2,000 for the loss of their residence, and that 5 different households in the world have been pressured to relocate to accommodate Hydro’s large re-engineering of the lands and waters of the area — the Churchill River Diversion (CRD).

The CRD successfully elevated the output of water from the Churchill River system into the Nelson River. The Missi Falls management construction close to South Indian Lake and the Notigi management construction simply west of Nelson Home management the circulate of water out of the Churchill and into the Rat and Burntwood Rivers, which ultimately stream into the Nelson.

However alongside the trail of these human-made channels and management buildings are communities like Nelson Home.

And households like Kobliski’s.

“We all had to move back on to the reserve with no home, nowhere to live, and we were scattered all over the community with relatives,” she recollects. “That’s how I grew up.”

“Everything we ate came from the land”

Nelson Home can also be residence to Ramona Neckoway, who has been main the Wa Ni Ska Tan alliance’s sixth annual tour of hydro-impacted communities and serving to her individuals community and find out how hydro development has affected others in the area.

Wa Ni Ska Tan means, “to wake up, or to rise up” in Cree, she defined to APTN on the primary day of the journey.

As such, an enormous half of the group’s mandate is not solely research-oriented, but in addition advocacy and solutions-oriented, she stated. Wa Ni Ska Tan, in working with group members, is exploring methods to assist perceive and mitigate the impacts of hydro development, whether or not it’s by way of funding analysis or land-based actions in communities, or internet hosting letter-writing occasions.

On the tail-end of their journey north, Neckoway brings her Wa Ni Ska Tan colleagues to Nelson Home.

She grew up after the CRD so doesn’t know what it was wish to have entry to wash consuming water straight out of the lake.

Standing on a dock behind her auntie’s home on the sting of the group, Neckoway tells the story, secondhand, of how her household members used to return down the financial institution to fetch water.

Now, she says, her mom, aunties and uncles spend as a lot time as potential at their household’s camp on the opposite aspect of the lake.

She’s on the brink of take the Wa Ni Ska Tan crowd there.

However earlier than she does, she humbly however truthfully shares one reservation she’s having.

“I don’t want us to be victimized,” she says considerably hesitantly, referring to the best way media typically portrays Indigenous peoples and the way these representations are sometimes then internalized.

“It doesn’t do us any good if we’re in the [victim] mindset. We have to empower ourselves. And we’d like individuals to respect basically that relationship and people views that the elders have concerning the land and the setting.

“There’s a reason why people are so upset here.”

Moments later we board a small boat and head throughout Footprint Lake to the camp.

A small log cabin sits about 150 ft in the woods again from the shore. Out entrance a big picket deck the place three of Necokway’s aunts and two uncles sit chatting with each other and consuming tea.

They’ve ready a meal of recent whitefish, pickerel and jackfish, fried bannock and coleslaw.

Edward Linklater tells APTN a narrative just like those we’ve heard in different hydro-impacted communities: The water was clear, drinkable; the lakes have been protected and navigable; the fishing and searching have been bountiful; the individuals have been happier than they’re now.

However now, he explains, going out on the water is dangerous, and fishing isn’t possible for many.

The separation of the individuals from their land and waters has introduced grave penalties.

“We are losing our language,” Linklater says. Youth have entry to Cree language packages in the varsity, nevertheless it’s not the identical as land-based studying, he explains.

“Even if they speak it, I can’t understand them.”

Edward Linklater

(Elder Edward Linklater, Ramona Neckoway’s uncle, says the separation of his individuals from the land and water resulting from hydro development has contributed to his individuals’s loss of their language. Photograph: Justin Brake)

Linklater additionally recollects deaths in the group he attributes to modifications in the waters resulting from hydro.

A ship two of his associates have been in, each of them fishermen, capsized years in the past.

“The current was so strong, the boat couldn’t handle it,” he says.

“Other people were swept away and their bodies were never found.”

Neckoway’s aunt Nina says she needs individuals in Southern Manitoba and Minnesota, who create demand for and eat the power Manitoba Hydro generates in the north, to know the true value of energy.

She says there was a time when “money didn’t matter” to her individuals. “The whole lot we ate got here from the land.

“But now all the animals are getting sick from the pollution,” she provides, explaining they don’t even eat fish from their very own lake as a result of considerations of mercury. Now they should journey out of the group to get their fish.

Neckoway says hydro development pressured her individuals out of their conventional financial system and into one which has had too unfavourable an impression of their well-being.

“Maybe capitalism, so to speak, is part of the problem,” she says.

Whereas they recognize the “modern amenities” and need alternatives, she says, “I kind of don’t feel that it should come at the expense of the environment.”

Desecration of a sacred website

Neckoway’s household take the Wa Ni Ska Tan members throughout Footprint Lake to the place the place the lake received its identify, and in addition as an example how Manitoba Hydro and the province regard the Cree in their pursuit of power and income.

We arrive at a cliff on the north shore of the lake, not removed from the group.

Because the boat approaches the cliff two circles embedded in the rock come into view. Inside every circle is what seems to be form of a footprint.

Nisachawayasihk Elder Donald Hart tells the story of Wisahkecahk and the way the Cree cultural hero got here to go away his footprints on the aspect of the rock cliff that when rested above the water.


However when Manitoba Hydro knowledgeable the Nisichawayasi Nehethowuk that the water ranges in their lake would rise drastically, there was little regard for the footprints regardless of concern from elders in the group.

In 1976, with the inundation of Footprint Lake, Wisahkecahk’s footprints have been underwater.

Elders continued in their misery over the desecration of the sacred website, and in 1977 the footprints have been reduce from the submerged rock face and transported to a museum in Winnipeg. The next yr they made their means again to the group, the place they have been placed on public show.

It will be a number of extra years earlier than elders and the group, nonetheless unsettled by the flooding and subsequent removing of the footprints, would have the footprints returned to their place on the aspect of Footprint Lake.

“They wanted them back, the people,” Hart explains, “because they figured it might be cursed over there [in the community], you know.”

The massive piece of rock as soon as minimize from beneath the water now sits atop the cliff. And Wisahkecahk’s footprints have been faraway from that rock and embedded again into the rock face 10 or 20 ft above their unique location, above water.

Nisichawayasihk Footprints

(The footprints of Wisahkecahk have been flooded by Manitoba Hydro in the 1970s, then faraway from their unique location and put in a museum earlier than being re-embedded into a brand new piece of rock. Peter Kulchyski says the desecration of the sacred website exhibits a blatant disregard for the Cree’s spiritual rights. Photograph: Justin Brake)

Within the woods about 50 ft past the cliff is the body of a sweat lodge.

Hart says individuals from his group return to the location for prayer and ceremony.

Peter Kulchyski, the professor of Native Research from College of Manitoba who helped launch Wa Ni Ska Tan and the visits to hydro-impacted communities, likens Manitoba Hydro’s flooding and desecration of the footprints to the demolition of the Sistine Chapel.

“They took one of the most sacred sites in the province and they ripped it out and travelled it around, and eventually sent it back to the site, though much higher up than they were,” he later tells APTN by telephone.

“I think that shows a brutal disregard for the cultural heritage of the Nehethowuk people. We pay lip service to freedom of religion, but actually Aboriginal spirituality apparently doesn’t count when it comes to freedom of religion and we will affect religious sites for money, and have done so.”

New relationships, similar outcomes

Manitoba Hydro says it has changed its methods because the days of forcing Indigenous individuals from their houses and flooding their ancestral lands.

Whereas they declined an interview for this collection, Hydro spokesperson Bruce Owen advised APTN by e-mail that “a lot has changed in Manitoba and Canada from [that] time interval.

“More stringent environmental regulations and licensing requirements are in place today than 50-60 years ago…[which] ensure that all our projects minimize their impact on the natural environment and the people who live there.”

The Wuskwatim and Keeyask dams, Owen says, have been “developed in partnership with local communities, who have the opportunity to participate in the planning of the projects and to have an equity stake in these projects should they so choose.”

However Kobliski says that consequently of Nisichawayasihk’s partnership on Wuskwatim, a 200-megawatt $1.three billion dam constructed close to Nelson Home, her group is dealing with tens of tens of millions of dollars of debt—to Manitoba Hydro, however—and no assure of a return on their funding.

In 2006, after virtually a decade of negotiations, Nisichawayasihk signed the Wuskwatim Challenge Development Settlement (WPDA) with Manitoba Hydro, which provides the First Nation a 33 per cent partnership on the 200-megawatt dam.

The fee to NCN was $28 million plus a $56 million mortgage from Manitoba Hydro itself, to be paid again out of anticipated future income.

However venture value overruns, the U.S. monetary crash of 2008 and a decreased demand for export power have pushed any risk of windfall income for NCN into the longer term.

The deal between NCN and Hydro has since been amended twice to guard the group from bearing the instant monetary burden of paying extra because of the unexpected circumstances.

However Kulchyski says NCN is “sinking deeper into debt,” and that the restructuring of the agreements have been carried out with out group votes.

“They’ve just been done between utility and the band council,” he says.

Kobliski says the individuals in her group have not given their free, prior and knowledgeable consent to the settlement as a result of “there wasn’t any proper consultation” with the restructuring.

She says she’s been looking for solutions from Chief Marcel Moody and council, however to no avail.

APTN reached out to Chief Moody for remark however did not obtain a response by the point of publication.

“No matter what we ask around here it falls on deaf ears,” Kobliski says. “We never get a response back. And it’s been like this for many, many years.”

Kobliski additionally says that not solely have dwelling circumstances in her group not improved because the band struck the cope with Hydro — they’ve gotten worse.

That features bearing in mind the $56 million implementation settlement Hydro settled with NCN in 1996 to compensate for the hurt brought on by the Churchill River Diversion in the late ‘70s.

“Ever since 1996, since the money came into our community…we’ve been having a lot of social problems in our community,” she explains.

“It was escalating to the point where gang members were coming in here selling drugs. We’ve had a lot of violence in our community, a lot of domestic violence, suicide, sexual assault,” she continues, including that “for the past 10 years it’s been really bad.”

Kobliski is a First Nation security officer for the band. She’s one of 16 officers who work with the RCMP officers in the group of 2,500, she says.

She insists that as somebody who checks automobiles coming into the group to implement alcohol limits she has particular perception into how her individuals are doing in the wake of NCN’s offers with Manitoba Hydro.

“I grew up in a community where there was not much alcohol…and now there’s cocaine, there’s crystal meth, there’s marijuana, there’s ecstasy — there’s so much,” she says.

“And the violence that we’re seeing in the group, it was so speedy. It’s virtually like there’s a disaster happening right here. The best way I see it, the place the cash goes, the drug sellers are going to comply with the cash.

Kobliski says belief cash from NCN and Hydro’s 1996 implementation settlement has funded necessary packages in the group and helped construct infrastructure.

In 2015 Chief Moody advised the Winnipeg Free Press, in an interview about restructuring the Wuskwatim deal, that the band is in reality depending on its cope with Manitoba Hydro to compensate for lack of federal help.

“We have no funding at all from the federal government to deal with housing and infrastructure,” he stated, explaining his “philosophy has always been that if the government isn’t going to help us we’re going to have to do it ourselves.”

However Kobliski factors to the group’s drug and alcohol remedy centre—and now a ladies’s disaster centre presently beneath development—as additional indicators the prosperity promised by hydro development has not come.

She says there have been points with consuming water in the group, and that some have fallen ailing.

Some, like herself, don’t drink the water as a result of they don’t belief it.

She recollects a childhood reminiscence of elders gathered in her grandfather’s residence.

“I remember him saying to the elders there that one day we will be buying water in water bottles. I used to wonder what he was talking about, and now I see it.”

Kobliski travels 75 kilometres to Thompson each week or two to purchase bottled consuming water, one thing not many group members can afford to do, she says.

“The only time we use water that’s coming from Nelson House is to shower with, and to wash our clothes, and to clear our house.”

She says her individuals “were fine the way we were” previous to hydro development in the area.

“Everybody helped one another. Nobody had to lock their doors. We didn’t have to worry about our children. And now it’s like everybody’s fighting to survive here. Nobody’s looking out for anybody anymore. There’s so much fear. We’re living in fear of one another,” she continues, laying half of the blame on the band’s management.

“It’s sad because the way our leaders made it sound when this project was coming through: we’re going to have this, we’re gonna have that, we’re gonna prosper. Well why are our people still living in poverty? Why are our homes still full of mould?”

Kobliski additionally warns that Manitoba Hydro’s messaging about company duty and First Nation partnerships is misleading.

“It looks good on the outside — they’re painting a good picture of the partnership, but inside the communities we’re all suffering,” she says.

“This is our territory”

Again on her auntie’s dock in Nelson Home Neckoway is obvious that her individuals don’t want sympathy, “because we can confront and contest what’s going on in a dignified way.”

However first that requires a public dialogue and understanding of the true nature of hydro development in her territory.

“My aunt used to tell me stories of my grandfather chasing away surveyors and people at Wuskwatim [Lake] in the ‘50s,” she says.

“So my mom grew up as they worked there. And then I was born into the Northern Flood Agreement, my daughter was born into the implementation agreement, and then my grandson inherited the [Wuskwatim] agreement.”

Nisichawayasihk Ramona Neckoway

(Ramona Neckoway says Nisichaswayasihk Cree Nation’s agreements with Manitoba Hydro over the previous 40 years “just keep getting worse and worse despite the narrative that this is an opportunity to be self-determining and self-governing.” Photograph: Justin Brake.)

“So those four generations, each of them has had their own experience,” she continues. “However three of 4 of them have inherited—been born into—these realities the place every era has their very own settlement.

However the agreements “simply hold getting worse and worse regardless of the narrative that this is a chance to be self-determining and self-governing. I don’t purchase that rhetoric, and I proceed to be so against this mannequin that was used up right here.

“This is our reality, and the fact that you’ve got 40 years worth of agreements, 40 years worth of promises, and we’re not getting any better…now I think we can actually talk about the social consequences of what’s going on,” Neckoway continues.

“And to me that’s tied to the loss of land, and the dispossession of culture, of land, of territory, of connections, kinship.”

Neckoway factors as much as the homes on the reservation.

“There’s a colonial context behind that,” she says. “This was the place individuals got here for church and faculty, [but] they lived in camps.

“People have bought into this idea that this Indian reserve is our boundary — but out boundary is out there,” she continues, pointing throughout the inexperienced waters of Footprint Lake on the hills past.

“This is our territory. The history’s out there. I can feel my ancestors out here, I can feel that connection.”

[email protected]

[email protected]

fbq(‘init’, ‘1900586643519394’); // Insert your pixel ID right here.
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);

fbq(‘init’, ‘528100980648029’); // Insert your pixel ID right here.
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);

fbq(‘init’, ‘1900586643519394’); // Insert your pixel ID right here.
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);